Friday, November 20, 2026

THE NEW MERIT: FROM REMEMBERING TO CREATING

  Education 2047 #Blog 69 (20 NOV 2026) 

Why AI Is Redefining What It Means to Be Meritorious

 

A thought-provoking message circulating on social media contrasts two young people. One, barely 22 years old, earns millions by creating digital content. The other, despite holding a university degree, delivers food to make ends meet.

The comparison may be exaggerated. Millions of content creators earn very little, and a graduate working in the gig economy should not be judged by the nature of that employment. Nevertheless, the message raises an uncomfortable question: Has the meaning of merit changed while our education system continues to reward its older definition?

For generations, we have told children to study hard, secure good grades, obtain a degree and expect a rewarding career. The arrangement was never guaranteed, but it carried sufficient credibility to shape the aspirations of families and the architecture of educational institutions.

Artificial intelligence is now challenging the assumptions beneath this arrangement.

When knowledge becomes abundantly accessible and machines can perform increasingly sophisticated intellectual tasks, the ability to remember and reproduce established knowledge can no longer distinguish individuals as it once did.

Perhaps it is time to reconsider what makes a person meritorious.

 

The Meritocracy We Inherited

Our educational system evolved in an era when access to knowledge was limited. Schools and universities brought together teachers, libraries, laboratories and accumulated disciplinary knowledge. Those who could acquire, retain and reproduce that knowledge successfully earned recognition through examinations, grades and degrees.

This system served an important historical purpose. Knowledge was scarce, and its acquisition represented a genuine advantage.

But the system also institutionalised a particular understanding of merit.

The student who reproduced the prescribed answer accurately was rewarded. The student who questioned the premise, explored an unconventional approach or attempted something original could find the exercise academically risky.

Over time, academic progression became closely associated with compliance, predictability and examination performance. Students learned to avoid mistakes because mistakes carried penalties.

This created an irony. Education celebrated innovation in its stated objectives while often discouraging the uncertainty from which innovation emerges.

And we continue to measure achievement through examinations largely concerned with what others have already discovered, established or created.

The AI-Induced Reversal

Humanity has continuously developed technologies to preserve, transmit and retrieve the outcomes of human thinking. Writing, printing, libraries, computing and the internet progressively reduced the need for individuals to personally retain everything they might need to know.

Artificial intelligence represents a further transformation. It makes not only stored knowledge but increasingly usable intelligence accessible on demand.

AI can explain concepts, generate code, analyse information, propose designs, synthesise literature and assist in solving complex problems. Many capabilities that previously required extensive formal training are becoming accessible to individuals with considerably less specialised education.

This does not make human knowledge or understanding irrelevant. It changes where their greatest value lies.

The person who knows more facts no longer necessarily enjoys an advantage over someone who knows how to frame a better problem, exercise judgement, recognise an opportunity and use available intelligence effectively.

In Bloom's revised taxonomy, Create occupies the highest level of the cognitive domain, above Remember, Understand, Apply, Analyse and Evaluate.

Yet educational assessment remains disproportionately concentrated on the lower levels.

If creation is the highest expression of cognitive learning, why do we assess students primarily on what others have already created?

That question exposes a fundamental misalignment between what education claims to value and what its assessment systems actually reward.

Creation Requires More Than Intelligence

It is tempting to assume that those who possess greater knowledge or intelligence are naturally more likely to create.

But human experience suggests otherwise.

Many highly accomplished individuals prefer established pathways. They seek certainty, follow familiar procedures and avoid situations where success cannot be predicted.

Creation demands something additional: the courage to enter the unknown.

An original idea has no established answer key. A new venture has no guaranteed outcome. An unfamiliar problem may require several unsuccessful attempts before a promising solution emerges.

This is where conventional discussions of higher-order cognitive skills remain incomplete.

Creation requires the convergence of three domains of learning.

The cognitive domain provides the capacity to imagine possibilities, analyse relationships, evaluate alternatives and develop original solutions.

The affective domain contributes curiosity, initiative, courage, resilience and the willingness to challenge established assumptions.

The psychomotor domain provides the practical ability to experiment, construct, execute and translate ideas into tangible outcomes.

An individual may have strong cognitive abilities but lack the confidence to attempt something original. Another may display considerable enthusiasm without the competence to execute. A third may possess excellent technical skills but never question the purpose or possibilities of the work being performed.

Meaningful creation brings these capabilities together.

We therefore need to distinguish between the ability to create and the willingness to create. Education must nurture both.

And this requires moving beyond the teaching of knowledge towards the formation of human capabilities and dispositions.

The Risk-Averse Student Is Not an Accident

Why do so many academically successful young people hesitate to take risks?

Part of the answer may lie in what we have trained them to do.

From an early age, students are expected to complete prescribed tasks, follow established methods and produce answers that match predetermined expectations.

Examinations reward certainty. Curricula reward coverage. Grades reward conformity to established standards.

Even when students undertake projects, they frequently work on problems whose solutions are already known to their teachers, available in textbooks or readily discoverable online.

Such activities can develop useful skills. But they do not necessarily cultivate originality.

We should not be surprised when students trained for years to minimise mistakes become reluctant to pursue uncertain outcomes.

The problem is not a shortage of talent. It is an educational architecture that often treats uncertainty as an obstacle rather than an opportunity for learning.

If we want creators, we must give learners experience in creating.

That means exposing them to unfamiliar problems, encouraging them to formulate questions, allowing experimentation and assessing the reasoning behind unsuccessful attempts—not merely the correctness of final answers.

From Answering Questions to Creating Possibilities

The implications for curriculum, teaching and assessment are profound.

I have long advocated that education should begin with challenges rather than chapters. Learners should encounter meaningful problems and acquire the knowledge required to address them along the way.

This reverses the conventional sequence.

Instead of completing a prescribed body of knowledge before attempting to apply it, students begin with situations that demand inquiry, experimentation, collaboration and judgement.

Teachers become facilitators and fellow investigators, not merely transmitters of established answers.

Learning environments become sandboxes where ideas can be explored, tested, revised and sometimes rejected.

Assessment, correspondingly, must move beyond checking whether students can reproduce expected answers.

We should evaluate the quality of the questions they formulate, the originality of their approaches, the soundness of their reasoning, the evidence supporting their conclusions and their ability to improve upon existing solutions.

Not every attempt must produce a commercially successful product, a patent or a startup.

A student who develops a better way of explaining a difficult concept, reduces waste in a local process, improves an assistive device or identifies an overlooked community problem has also demonstrated creativity.

Creation must be understood broadly as generating something original and valuable in its context.

The central question is no longer simply, What does the student know?

It becomes, What can the student accomplish with the knowledge and intelligence available?

The Emerging Meaning of Merit

Academic credentials have traditionally served as signals of capability. Employers and society used degrees and grades as convenient indicators of what individuals might be able to accomplish.

But a credential is not the capability itself.

The distinction becomes increasingly important when AI can assist individuals in performing tasks once associated with formal qualifications.

Someone without an advanced degree may identify an opportunity, use AI effectively, mobilise collaborators and create considerable value.

Meanwhile, someone with impressive academic credentials may find that the capabilities certified by those credentials are no longer sufficiently distinctive.

Neither outcome is inevitable. Credentials still matter in many professions, and economic success depends on circumstances well beyond individual merit.

Nevertheless, the basis for recognising merit is changing.

I have proposed Credible Capability as a more meaningful basis for recognising what an individual can actually do.

Rather than relying primarily on transcripts and grades, we should look for verifiable evidence of capability: problems addressed, solutions created, judgements exercised, contributions made and outcomes validated.

Such evidence should include not only successful achievements but also the quality of inquiry, integrity of methods and learning demonstrated through experimentation.

Creation should not become another narrowly defined metric that encourages superficial projects, inflated claims or a race to accumulate patents and startups.

The purpose is to recognise genuine capability, not merely replace one system of counting with another.

Beyond Creation: The Ability to Enable Others

There is another dimension worth considering.

Bloom's revised taxonomy culminates in Create. But should human capability development necessarily end there?

I have suggested an additional level: Transfer of Capability.

An individual who creates something valuable demonstrates a high level of capability. An individual who can enable others to acquire that capability multiplies its impact.

This is especially significant for teachers, researchers, mentors and institutional leaders.

A researcher who makes a discovery contributes new knowledge. A researcher who develops others into independent investigators extends the capacity for discovery.

An entrepreneur who builds a successful enterprise creates value. One who also enables others to become capable entrepreneurs expands the possibilities available to society.

This introduces an important social dimension to the new meritocracy.

Merit should not be understood exclusively as outperforming others. It should also recognise the ability to expand what others can accomplish.

Creation distinguishes capability. Transfer of capability multiplies it.

Education 2047: Redefining What We Reward

The age of AI demands more than incorporating new technologies into existing classrooms.

If AI increasingly performs tasks associated with remembering, understanding and applying established knowledge, continuing to organise education primarily around these activities risks preserving capabilities whose scarcity is declining.

Human education must move towards higher cognitive achievement, supported by affective development and practical competence.

It must nurture people who are willing to question, capable of exercising judgement, prepared to venture into uncertainty and competent to create.

The transition will not be easy. Institutions have spent generations perfecting systems for delivering prescribed knowledge, conducting examinations and awarding credentials.

But preserving familiar structures cannot be the purpose of education.

The purpose must be to develop human beings capable of contributing meaningfully to a changing world.

We must stop confusing academic progression with human development, and examination performance with credible capability.

The old meritocracy largely rewarded those who could demonstrate that they knew what others had already discovered.

The emerging meritocracy must increasingly recognise those who can create what does not yet exist—and enable others to do likewise.

Perhaps the most important examination question for Education 2047 is one that our institutions must answer themselves:

If creation represents the highest level of cognitive achievement, why do we continue to assess our students primarily on what others have already created?

Until we address that contradiction, we may continue producing highly qualified graduates without nurturing enough independent creators.

In the age of AI, merit will increasingly be defined not by how much one can remember, but by what one has the capability—and courage—to create.

Education now is what cannot be downloaded.

                                                               * * *  

 

Author

Dr. Neeraj Saxena is a former Scientist at TIFAC/DST and co-author of Educational Roadmap of India's Technology Vision 2035, with subsequent advisory roles at AICTE spanning higher education policy and implementation. He is currently Pro-Chancellor of JIS University, Kolkata, and publishes on AI-induced transformation in education through the Education2047 platform [nrj2000.blogspot.com] & [nrjsaxenajisu.substack.com]


©Dr. Neeraj Saxena, 2026 | CC BY-NC-ND 4.0 | Attribution required | No commercial use | No derivatives without permission.

Monday, October 26, 2026

FROM ELIGIBILITY TO CAPABILITY: WHAT SHOULD A DEGREE CERTIFY?

 

 Education 2047 #Blog 68 (27 OCT 2026) 

Why higher cognition, human formation and demonstrated action must replace the knowledge-worker model of conventional education

 

A Degree Opens the Door. But Can Its Holder Walk Through It?

For generations, a university degree has served as a passport to opportunity. It establishes eligibility for employment, competitive examinations, postgraduate education and numerous other pursuits. Society has generally accepted that someone who has successfully completed a degree programme possesses the knowledge and capabilities expected of a graduate.

But eligibility and capability are not the same.

A graduate may possess a degree in economics without being able to examine a local economic problem. A science graduate may reproduce established theories but struggle to design an investigation. A graduate in political science may explain democratic institutions yet lack the ability to facilitate dialogue among people holding conflicting views.

These are not necessarily failures of individual students. They raise questions about what degree programmes are designed to accomplish.

Conventional non-professional programmes largely evolved to prepare knowledge workers. Their organising principle was the acquisition of disciplinary knowledge, and their assessment systems primarily measured how successfully students could demonstrate that acquisition.

Such a model had considerable utility when access to organised knowledge was limited and occupations required people to retrieve, interpret and apply information.

Artificial intelligence is changing that environment.

If machines can increasingly perform routine cognitive tasks, what precisely should a university certify after three or four years of education?

The Cognitive Ceiling We Have Created

Benjamin Bloom's familiar cognitive taxonomy moves from remembering and understanding through applying and analysing to evaluating and creating.

Yet a significant proportion of conventional undergraduate education remains concentrated near the lower levels.

Students attend lectures, prepare notes, reproduce explanations, solve familiar problems and answer questions framed by others. Even where higher-order thinking appears in learning outcomes, examinations frequently reward the reproduction of established knowledge or rehearsed methods.

There is a fundamental contradiction here.

Students entering higher education have already spent approximately twelve years acquiring foundational knowledge. University education should increasingly demand analysis, evaluation, creation and independent inquiry. Instead, conventional teaching and examination practices often continue to reward capabilities that AI can now replicate with remarkable speed.

This does not mean remembering and understanding have become irrelevant. They remain essential foundations of cognition. But foundations should not be mistaken for the building.

A graduate who can explain a problem already solved by others is different from one who can recognise an unfamiliar problem, decide what knowledge is needed, develop a defensible approach and establish whether the proposed solution works.

The second graduate possesses something beyond accumulated knowledge.

The second possesses demonstrable capability.

Even Higher Cognitive Capabilities Are Not Enough

Much of the contemporary discussion about educational reform calls for greater emphasis on critical thinking, creativity, problem-solving and innovation.

These are necessary changes. But I believe they are insufficient.

Human capability cannot be reduced to cognition alone.

Consider a student who can devise an excellent technical solution but cannot cooperate with others. Another may demonstrate outstanding analytical ability but little concern for the people affected by a decision. A third may propose a sophisticated intervention but lack the practical ability to test or implement it.

All three may perform exceptionally well in conventional examinations.

Would we consider them fully prepared?

Education has long recognised three domains of learning: cognitive, affective and psychomotor. Yet their treatment in conventional degree programmes is profoundly uneven.

Domain

What must be developed

How capability becomes visible

Cognitive

Analysis, judgement, creation and independent inquiry

Investigations, explanations, decisions and original contributions

Affective

Empathy, ethical responsibility, collaboration, perseverance and openness

Conduct under real constraints, peer interaction, reflection and responsible choices

Psychomotor

Practical execution, skilled use of tools, experimentation and refinement

Demonstrations, prototypes, performances, field activities and reliable execution

 

The relative importance of these domains will differ across disciplines and intended capabilities. Psychomotor capability in experimental science or design may look very different from the skilled performance involved in communication, the arts or field research.

However, the larger principle remains: a person's intellectual ability is not the complete measure of their capability.

Indeed, as AI makes cognitive assistance increasingly accessible, the qualities that determine how people use intelligence may become even more consequential.

These Capabilities Cannot Be Developed Through Lectures Alone

We cannot develop empathy merely by teaching its definition.

We cannot develop ethical judgement only by asking students to reproduce theories of ethics.

We cannot establish practical capability by evaluating whether someone can describe a procedure.

Such capabilities require experiences in which learners must act, make choices, confront uncertainty, cooperate, reflect and improve.

That is why field engagement, authentic challenges, community interaction, experimentation and sustained group activities must move from the margins of undergraduate education to its centre.

Imagine students investigating a recurring waterlogging problem in a neighbourhood.

They must understand rainfall patterns, drainage, land use and relevant public infrastructure. These are cognitive requirements.

They must interact respectfully with residents, recognise conflicting interests, work across disciplinary boundaries and consider the consequences of their recommendations. These involve the affective domain.

They must collect observations, use instruments or digital tools, conduct field surveys, interpret measurements and perhaps construct and test a model. These involve practical and psychomotor capabilities.

The problem does not arrive conveniently divided into academic subjects or learning domains.

Why should education remain divided in that manner?

From Answering Questions to Discovering What Should Be Asked

Conventional examinations begin with questions formulated by teachers. Students are expected to produce acceptable answers within a prescribed time.

But the ability to answer a given question is becoming a less distinctive indicator of human capability when an AI system can often produce an impressive response almost instantly.

The ability to recognise what deserves investigation becomes increasingly important.

Can a student identify a problem that others have overlooked? Can they distinguish an important question from a trivial one? Can they recognise that their original assumption was wrong? Can they formulate a question that opens a productive direction for inquiry?

These capabilities require considerably more than retrieving information.

In my proposed four-quadrant framework, higher education should progressively move learners towards the Unknown Area, Unknown Questions (UAUQ) quadrant, where neither the complete territory nor the questions are predetermined.

At this level, learning is not simply about reaching a known answer. It involves discovering problems, constructing meaningful questions and determining how those questions might be investigated.

AI can participate powerfully in this process, but students must demonstrate intellectual ownership of their inquiry, judgement and conclusions.

The ability to frame and assess questions should therefore become an explicit component of undergraduate assessment.

What, Then, Should Three or Four Years Certify?

A degree should represent more than the successful completion of prescribed courses and examinations.

It should establish credible evidence that the graduate can accomplish meaningful work, exercise judgement and continue developing capabilities when confronted with unfamiliar situations.

This requires a shift in what universities document.

Conventional certification

Capability-oriented certification

Courses successfully completed

Challenges meaningfully undertaken

Credits and grades accumulated

Capabilities demonstrated through evidence

Answers evaluated against prescribed expectations

Questions, methods, decisions and outcomes evaluated

Individual examination performance

Individual contribution within independent and collaborative work

Knowledge acquired in separate subjects

Knowledge integrated across relevant domains

Qualification establishes eligibility

Qualification establishes eligibility supported by credible capability evidence

 

This need not mean abandoning grades, credits or degrees immediately. They serve important administrative and regulatory purposes.

But they are insufficient as complete descriptions of a graduate.

A richer record could include verified projects, field investigations, prototypes, research contributions, reflective accounts, evidence of collaboration, and assessments of ethical conduct and responsibility.

Such a record must distinguish genuine individual contribution from group achievement or AI-generated output. It must also allow capability to be demonstrated through different forms of evidence, rather than imposing a single performance model on every learner.

The result would be a Credible Capability Portrait: a verifiable account of what a graduate knows, can accomplish, and has demonstrated through responsible action.

Unlike a conventional transcript, it would describe capability rather than merely record academic transactions.

The Faculty Must Also Change

There is an uncomfortable implication for universities.

If we expect students to develop capabilities through unfamiliar problems, faculty must themselves be capable of facilitating such learning.

A teacher who has spent years delivering a fixed syllabus may be highly knowledgeable in a discipline but may not yet possess the capabilities required to mentor multidisciplinary investigations, manage diverse groups, evaluate student-formulated questions or assess affective and psychomotor development.

Faculty development programmes must therefore move beyond content updates and demonstrations of new technologies.

Faculty need experiences in curating authentic problems, developing assessment rubrics, facilitating collaborative inquiry, supporting learner autonomy and exercising judgement where no predetermined answer exists.

They should also engage with unfamiliar problems themselves, sometimes learning alongside their students.

This does not diminish the teacher's role. It makes that role more demanding and potentially more valuable.

The teacher is no longer merely responsible for ensuring that students receive knowledge.

The teacher becomes responsible for creating conditions in which students can develop and demonstrate capability.

Beyond Employability

It would be a mistake to interpret this argument solely as a demand for job-ready graduates.

Employment is important, but a university education has a larger purpose.

Graduates are also members of families, communities and democratic societies. They will confront ethical dilemmas, technological disruptions, environmental challenges and situations for which no existing syllabus can provide complete answers.

They may change occupations several times. Some will create enterprises. Others will pursue research, public service, community initiatives or paths that do not yet exist.

A university that prepares students only for currently advertised jobs risks becoming obsolete as those jobs change.

A university that develops their capacity to inquire, act, collaborate, judge and learn independently is preparing them for a much longer future.

Employability may be one consequence of education. Human capability must be its larger purpose.

The Question Universities Can No Longer Avoid

In an earlier article, The Sunset of the Conventional Course, I argued that universities must distinguish between preserving valuable disciplines and preserving academic programmes whose original purposes have weakened.

The present question goes deeper.

Even if we redesign courses, introduce multidisciplinary choices and make curricula more flexible, what will have changed if graduates continue to be assessed primarily on their ability to reproduce knowledge?

We may replace the academic container without changing what it contains.

The real transformation begins when universities redefine what successful graduation signifies.

Not merely that a learner has completed a prescribed sequence.

Not merely that the learner has accumulated sufficient credits.

Not even merely that the learner can think critically.

But that the learner has demonstrated the capability to understand unfamiliar situations, formulate worthwhile questions, mobilise knowledge, act effectively, engage responsibly with others and learn beyond the university.

A degree may establish eligibility. Education must establish capability.

The future credibility of universities may depend on whether they can demonstrate the difference.


 * * * 


Author

Dr. Neeraj Saxena is a former Scientist at TIFAC/DST and co-author of Educational Roadmap of India's Technology Vision 2035, with subsequent advisory roles at AICTE spanning higher education policy and implementation. He is currently Pro-Chancellor of JIS University, Kolkata, and publishes on AI-induced transformation in education through the Education2047 platform [nrj2000.blogspot.com] & [nrjsaxenajisu.substack.com]


©Dr. Neeraj Saxena, 2026 | CC BY-NC-ND 4.0 | Attribution required | No commercial use | No derivatives without permission.